Policy A

Term Life

VS
Policy B

Indexed Universal Life

Pure protection vs. tax-free retirement income — these aren't the same product.

Agents often pitch IUL as "better than term because it builds cash value." That's the wrong framing. Term and IUL solve different problems. Term replaces income if you die young. IUL, when structured properly for someone who's already maxing traditional retirement accounts, provides tax-free retirement income with a life insurance wrapper. Confusing the two leads to expensive mistakes.

Head to head

Side-by-side breakdown

Term Life Category Indexed Universal Life
✓ $18–$45 Monthly cost (sample $500K) $200–$600
10–30 years Coverage duration Permanent
No Builds cash value Yes — index-linked
N/A Downside protection Credited interest can't go negative 0% floor
N/A Upside potential Varies by carrier and index 8–12% typical cap
Fixed Death benefit flexibility ✓ Adjustable
Fixed Premium flexibility ✓ Flexible (within limits)
✓ Simple Complexity Illustrations can be misleading Complex
No Tax-free retirement income When funded properly ✓ Yes (policy loans)
Compare any two policies
VS

The bottom line

Term for protection. IUL only after you've maxed retirement accounts.

If you need life insurance, buy term. Full stop. IUL is not a replacement for cheap, efficient protection — it's an advanced financial planning tool for people who've already maxed a 401(k) and Roth IRA and need another tax-advantaged bucket. IUL sold as "investment + insurance" to someone who hasn't done the basics first is almost always the wrong choice.

Decision guide

Which one fits your situation?

Term Life

Choose Term Life if…

  • You need life insurance protection — full stop
  • You have dependents who need income replacement
  • You want the simplest, cheapest path to coverage
  • You haven't yet maxed your 401(k) and Roth IRA
Learn more about Term Life →
Indexed Universal Life

Choose Indexed Universal Life if…

  • You've maxed every traditional retirement account
  • You want tax-free retirement income alongside coverage
  • You're a high-income earner needing another tax shelter
  • You're working with an independent agent who runs realistic illustrations
Learn more about Indexed Universal Life →
Still not sure?

Talk to an independent agent who knows both

An independent agent isn't tied to one product or carrier. They'll run real numbers for your situation — not a one-size-fits-all pitch.

No spam. Direct connection to a local agent.

More comparisons